4:17pm

Tue December 17, 2013
Sports

Some Competitors Say Free-Diving Needs A Safety Sea Change

Originally published on Wed December 18, 2013 12:31 am

Dahab, Egypt, just north of Sharm el-Sheikh on the Sinai Peninsula, is perfect for free-diving. A diver can have tea in a simple beach cafe and then take just a handful of steps into the Gulf of Aqaba, where the seafloor plunges more than 100 yards into a wine-glass-shaped blue hole.

Free-divers, who take a breath, swim as deep into the ocean as possible and then come back up, come to Dahab from across the world to compete. But a diver's death in November has raised questions about the safety of the sport, with some divers saying too little has been done to cut down on overly ambitious competitors and common injuries.

At a recent competition in Dahab — the first since diver Nick Mevoli died in the Bahamas — a dozen competitors had strung their yellow buoys out in a row across the blue hole. Each buoy had a weighted rope attached, which the divers followed down into the blue abyss.

One ... two ... then three minutes would go by. And then, a diver would come back up with a tag that proved he had reached the bottom.

But not all the scheduled divers competed that day. Maxim Iskander, a Canadian-Egyptian free-diver, withdrew from competition because of an injury known as a lung squeeze.

"How did I know? I spit a little bit of blood," Iskander says. "Not that much, but enough to tell you, OK, something happened."

Part of Iskander's caution stems from what happened to Mevoli. "I said to myself, 'I might as well rest and not make any stupid mistakes, especially considering what happened with Nick,' " Iskander says. "Everybody got pretty shocked from what happened."

Competition officials haven't yet determined the official cause of Mevoli's death, but everyone in the community knows the telltale signs of a lung squeeze: blood and shortness of breath.

When the body dives deep, the weight of the water presses the lungs and the air sacs inside. Picture a paper bag full of blueberries; when your hand's relaxed, you can compress the bag carefully enough to avoid squashing the berries. But any twists or jerks can cause ruptures.

Mevoli contorted his body several times on his last dive, aborting twice, only to turn back down to finish. Iskander calls that extreme.

"Personally, I would have never even thought about doing anything similar to that because there is a very high risk of squeezing then," Iskander says.

In the first competition since Mevoli's death, organizers asked divers not to compete if they had experienced a squeeze in the past month. They also limited the depth by which divers could attempt to exceed their personal record.

"We all sat here thinking the sport is very safe. And obviously we've got to react to this until we get some feedback ... to see what the results of Nick was and what actually happened," says free-dive instructor Brian Crossland, who was running the competition. "We've got to err on the side of caution."

Squeezes are common in free-diving. Judges and safety divers describe athletes surfacing, posing for YouTube and then ducking behind a buoy to spit up slicks of blood flecked with white body tissue.

Sara Campbell, a four-time world record free-diver, says the sport has grown complacent with these injuries, like one she witnessed at the free-diving world championships in 2011.

"A fountain of blood. Everyone trying to help him was covered in it. It was gruesome," she recalls. "Once they got him breathing again, he was taken to hospital, he was treated for the lung injury and he's fine."

On the one hand, Campbell and others blame overly ambitious competitors who have seen other divers return from death unscathed, wrapped in a cocoon of safety divers and medics. Mevoli, she says, inherited this complacency.

But Campbell also criticizes AIDA, the organization that governs competitive free-diving. She says the group isn't proactive enough in publishing accident reports.

Kimmo Lahtinen, AIDA's president, says the organization isn't covering anything up. Rather, he says, it's victim to the paralysis of an all-volunteer organization that's run democratically.

"When you try to lead this kind of multicultural and challenging organization, which is actually nonprofit as well, it's not easy to make fast decisions quite often," Lahtinen says. "So I can agree that we are not the fastest organization, maybe, in the world. But we try to do our best."

Lahtinen also says there are downsides to ramping up regulation. Competitors could start lying to judges and medical staff, he says, or worse, the sport could go underground, where there are no safety or education infrastructures.

Currently there is a special AIDA work group investigating the factors that contributed to Mevoli's death. Lahtinen says the report will likely recommend rule changes similar to those implemented at the Dahab competition.

Copyright 2013 WSHU Public Radio Group. To see more, visit http://www.wshu.org/.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

This is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News. I'm Melissa Block. Take a deep breath and then dive down into the ocean as far as possible then come back up. That's the competitive sport known as free diving. Last month, a Brooklyn man dived trying to set a new American record, 236 feet deep. His death has prompted a new focus on safety. Charles Lane of member station WSHU has been free diving for five years. He recently attended the first competition since the fatal accident.

CHARLES LANE, BYLINE: Dahab, Egypt, we're just north of Sharm el-Sheikh on the Sinai Peninsula, and it's really perfect for free diving here because you can have tea in one of these simple beach cafes and then take not 20 steps into the Gulf of Aqaba, where the sea floor plunges more than 100 yards into a wine-glass-shaped blue hole.

Free divers from across the world come here to rain and compete. I'm looking at a dozen competitor right now. Their yellow buoys are strung out row across the blue hole in a row. Each one has a weighted rope that the divers follow down into the blue abyss. One minute goes by, two minutes go by, three minutes go by and then, the diver comes back up with a tag proving that he was at the bottom.

But not all the divers competed today. One dropped out. Maxim Iskander is a Canadian-Egyptian free diver and he withdrew from competition today because of an injury known as a lung squeeze.

MAXIM ISKANDER: How did I know? I spit a little bit of blood. Not that much, but enough to tell you, OK, something happened. I said to myself, I might as well rest and not make any stupid mistakes, especially considering what happened with Nick from New York, actually. So everybody got pretty shocked from what happened.

LANE: Nick Mevoli, he died in November after surfacing from a dive in the Bahamas. Competition officials haven't yet determined the official cause of death, but everyone in the community knows the telltale signs of a lung squeeze, shortness of breath and blood. When the body goes deep, the weight of the water presses the lungs and the alveoli inside.

Picture a paper bag full of blueberries. If you're relaxed, you can compress that bag carefully enough to avoid squashing the berries. But any twists or jerks can cause ruptures. Mevoli did this several times, aborting twice but changing his mind and turning back down. Iskander calls that extreme.

ISKANDER: Personally, I would have never even thought about doing anything similar to that because there is a very high risk of squeezing then.

LANE: In the first competition since Mevoli's death, organizers asked divers not to compete if they had experienced a squeeze in the last month. They also limited the depth by which divers can exceed their personal best. Free dive instructor Brian Crossland is running today's event.

BRIAN CROSSLAND: We all sat here thinking the sport is very safe. And obviously we've got to react to this until we get some feedback just to see what the results of Nick was and what actually happened. We've got to err on the side of caution.

LANE: In free diving, squeezes are common. Judges and safety divers describe athletes surfacing, posing for YouTube and then ducking behind a buoy to spit up slicks of blood flecked with white body tissue.

SARA CAMPBELL: A fountain of blood. Everyone trying to help him was covered in it. It was gruesome.

LANE: Sara Campbell is a four-time world record free diver. She says the sport has grown complacent with these injuries, like the one she witnessed at the world championships in 2011.

CAMPBELL: He was taken to hospital. Once he got him breathing again, he was taken to hospital and he's fine.

LANE: On the one hand, Campbell and others blame overly ambitious competitors who have seen other divers return from death unscathed, wrapped in a cocoon of safety divers and medics. Mevoli, she says, inherited this complacency. But Campbell also criticizes AIDA, the organization governing competitive free diving. She says the group isn't proactive enough in publishing accident reports.

Kimmo Lahtinen is AIDA's president. He says AIDA isn't covering anything up. Rather, it's victim to the paralysis of an all-volunteer organization that's run democratically.

KIMMO LAHTINEN: When you try to lead this kind of multicultural and challenging organization, which is actually nonprofit as well, it's not easy to make fast decisions quite often. So I can agree that we are not the fastest organization, maybe, in the world. But we try to do our best.

LANE: Lahtinen also describes downfalls to ramping up regulation. Competitors could start lying to judges and medical staff or worse, the sport could go underground, where there are no safety or education infrastructures. Currently, there is a special AIDA work group investigating the contributing factors to Mevoli's death. Lahtinen says the report will likely recommend rule changes similar to those implemented at this Dahab competition.

For NPR News, I'm Charles Lane. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.