5:03pm

Thu July 11, 2013
Movie Reviews

A New Day, A Last Day, For One Man At 'Fruitvale Station'

Originally published on Fri July 12, 2013 6:19 pm

Fruitvale Station, on the Oakland side of the San Francisco Bay: Grainy cellphone video from a day, four years ago, that commanded the nation's attention. Several young black men sit on a transit station platform, white transit police officers standing over them. There's shouting, scuffling, but nothing that looks worrisome.

Then what sounds like a shot.

The movie proper backs up roughly 24 hours; it's the morning before the calendar ticks over to 2009. Twenty-two-year-old Oscar Grant (now played by actor Michael B. Jordan) is telling his girlfriend that things are looking up.

He's bluffing, but he means it. They have a 4-year-old daughter he adores and is great with, and though he's had a checkered past, he says he's determined to do better. Two years earlier, he'd spent a much less pleasant New Year's Eve in jail. And no, he does not want to go back to that.

So he heads out to convince an ex-boss to hire him back. And as Oscar goes through his day, struggling to stay positive in a world that keeps trying to knock him off stride, first-time director Ryan Coogler does something at once subtle and smart. He lets us see the Oscar that transit cops will see that night — dressed urban-tough, looking sketchy — as we hear the Oscar his family knows.

As the day goes on, you register Oscar's warmth and generosity — how yes, he can be irresponsible but also means well. Mundane stuff, really. He's just a guy.

And that night, over his grandma's gumbo, as he's talking about his plans to go into the city to watch the New Year's fireworks, his mom (Octavia Spencer) says what any protective mom would say:

"Why don't you take the train out there? That way you guys can drink, and hang out, and not have to worry about anything."

And we slip into Greek tragedy.

Fruitvale Station isn't really a surprising film, except insofar as it's rare to see such a warmly emotional big-screen portrait of black family life. The director, who grew up just north of Oakland and is about the age Oscar would be today, has said that for him there was a jarring that-could-have-been-me aspect to the story.

He's given it an immediacy and resonance on screen that reflects that — with help from a striking performance by Jordan, who's mostly had supporting roles before this on TV's Parenthood and Friday Night Lights. Together, star and director get you to look at, and think about, a flawed young man you might not give a second thought if you saw him on the street.

And also to look at, and think about, that reaction — and other knee-jerk reactions, and the consequences they can have. Fruitvale Station doesn't have anything shattering to say about the case, or the man, really. But it may well leave you shattered by his story. (Recommended)

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

For San Francisco residents who use the Bay Area Rapid Transit system, this will be a familiar announcement.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: Next stop: Fruitvale Station.

SIEGEL: The stop on the Oakland side of the bay was the site of a police shooting four years ago that led to massive protests. Now, the event that inspired those protests has inspired a movie. The film, "Fruitvale Station," has won prizes at both the Sundance and Cannes film festivals, and critic Bob Mondello says it deserves every bit of the buzz it's getting.

BOB MONDELLO, BYLINE: The opening shots are grainy cellphone video of the real event: several young black men seated on a transit station platform, white officers standing over them. There's shouting, scuffling, but nothing that looks worrisome, then what sounds like a shot. The movie proper backs up roughly 24 hours from there. It's the morning before the calendar ticks over to 2009.

Twenty-two-year-old Oscar Grant, now played by actor Michael B. Jordan, is telling his girlfriend things are looking up. He's bluffing, but he means it. They have a 4-year-old daughter he adores and is great with. And though he's had a checkered past, he says he's determined to do better. Two years earlier, he'd spent a much less pleasant New Year's Eve in jail talking to his mother.

(SOUNDBITE OF MOVIE, "FRUITVALE STATION")

OCTAVIA SPENCER: (as Wanda) That baby doesn't deserve this, Oscar.

MICHAEL B. JORDAN: (as Oscar Grant) You don't know what's going on.

SPENCER: (as Wanda) So I guess that's why she asked me why you love taking your vacations more than you like being with her.

JORDAN: (as Oscar Grant) Ma, you got to tell her I love her. Tell her I ain't never going to leave her.

SPENCER: (as Wanda) Tell her yourself. The next time you call home, you tell her yourself. Or better yet, let her come visit you here.

JORDAN: (as Oscar Grant) ...She don't need to be exposed...

SPENCER: (as Wanda) You already exposed her. You already exposed her to...

MONDELLO: No, he does not want to go back to that. So he heads out to convince an ex-boss to hire him back. And as Oscar goes through his day, struggling to stay positive in a world that keeps trying to knock him off stride, first-time director Ryan Coogler does something at once subtle and smart. He lets us see the Oscar that transit cops will see that night - dressed urban-tough, looking sketchy - as we hear the Oscar his family knows.

(SOUNDBITE OF MOVIE, "FRUITVALE STATION")

JORDAN: (as Oscar Grant) Chuck E. Cheese.

ARIANA NEAL: (as Katie) Really?

JORDAN: (as Oscar Grant) I promise. Daddy's going to give you a heck of tokens that we're going to play all the games. OK? And then we're going to get your favorite pizza and we'll eat it all up. Even Mommy's because she can't have carbs.

NEAL: (as Katie) What's a carb?

JORDAN: (as Oscar Grant) You ain't got to worry about that right now.

MONDELLO: As the day goes on, you register Oscar's warmth and generosity, how, yes, he can be irresponsible but also means well. Mundane stuff, really. He's just a guy. And that night, over his grandma's gumbo, as he's talking about his plans to go into the city to watch the New Year's fireworks, his mom says what any protective mom would say.

(SOUNDBITE OF MOVIE, "FRUITVALE STATION")

SPENCER: (as Wanda) Why don't you take the train out there?

MONDELLO: And we slip into Greek tragedy.

(SOUNDBITE OF MOVIE, "FRUITVALE STATION")

SPENCER: (as Wanda) That way you guys can drink and hang out and not have to worry about anything. No traffic either. You know it's going to be crazy going and coming back.

JORDAN: (as Oscar Grant) Yeah, we might take it.

MONDELLO: "Fruitvale Station" is not really a surprising film, except insofar as it's rare to see such a warmly emotional big-screen portrait of black family life. The director, who grew up just north of Oakland and is about the age Oscar would be today, has said that there was that-could-have-been-me aspect to the story.

He's given it an immediacy and resonance on screen that reflects that, with help from a striking performance by Michael B. Jordan, who's mostly had supporting roles before this on TV's "Parenthood" and "Friday Night Lights." Together, star and director get you to look at and think about a flawed young man you might not give a second thought if you saw him on the street.

And also to look at and think about that reaction and other knee-jerk reactions and the consequences they can have. "Fruitvale Station" doesn't have anything shattering to say about the case, or the man, really. But it may well leave you shattered by his story. I'm Bob Mondello. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.